Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery is a brick-and-mortar coin and bullion dealer located at 640 S Washington Blvd #100 in Sarasota, FL. The shop serves collectors, heirs, and investors in the Sarasota area with a focus on numismatics and transactions involving precious metals. Visitors will find a traditional retail showroom environment where items can be evaluated in person and deals can be completed at the counter. The business can be reached at 1 941-366-2191 for questions about availability, selling items, or arranging an in-store visit.
Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery maintains a two-way market for coins and precious metal items, providing a local venue to sell individual pieces or entire collections and to purchase collectible coins or bullion. Typical shop activity in this category includes United States and world coins, circulated and uncirculated material, certified pieces, and bullion-related items. Customers comparing options to buy gold bullion or add common silver issues to a stack can discuss inventory and timing directly with the counter staff. The store also assists people who are consolidating or dispersing inherited collections by evaluating holdings and outlining disposition options. For those researching specific series or key dates, the gallery can review items and provide condition and authenticity opinions before a sale. If you are traveling with high-value items or bulk quantities, calling ahead is a practical step to plan the visit.
Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery operates an open storefront in Sarasota, which allows customers to transact face to face and verify items prior to purchase or sale. Prospective buyers and sellers often consult multiple third-party sources such as Google Business Profile, the Better Business Bureau, and Yelp to review recent customer feedback. Because ratings and commentary change over time, it is best to read the most recent reviews, look for recurring themes about communication and transaction transparency, and note how the business responds to any concerns. For larger deals, consider confirming identification, payment methods, and any return or holding policies in advance.
I had thousands of baseball, football and hockey cards. Peter has worked with me to go through all of them. He has been absolutely wonderful to work with. He is honest, fair and trusting. His knowledge of the field is beyond reproach. I would highly recommend him.
I went there to sell some gold jewelry and Silver. The person I spoke with seamed to have a problem with buying the gold cross I had and was not interested. The watch I showed him was a Bulova. I paid $300 for it from Kenney G. He told me that it was only worth $5. He offered me $100 for an 18 inch 10K white gold chain. Spot for silver at the time I was there was almost $34. He offered me $150 for 1-Silver Bar, 4-Buffalo Rounds & 1-Silver Eagle. All were well preserved in capsules. I told him that I would go somewhere else. Everything they say in their advertisement is false. If you want a fair offer for your Silver or Gold I would go somewhere else.
As a woman, new to investing in silver, the staff was very helpful and courteous. I did my research and they have the best prices. I appreciated their time and expertise. Highly recommended!
Great prices! They saved me money! I highly recommend them for gold and silver bullion purchases.